TATA not for subscriber based spectrum allocation

After raising questions over the current subscriber-based policy for allocation of additional spectrum, Tatas have now extended this stand on the 3G spectrum saying such a criteria should not be followed.

On the same issue in their response to TRAI's 3G spectrum consultation issue, Reliance Communications, Cellular Operators' Association views remain more or less similar.

While COAI is asking for continuation of the present approach based on equitable assignment to GSM/CDMA, the CDMA association, AUSPI said 5Mhz should be the initial allocation and reservation of another carrier and is seeking equal spectrum for all operators.

On the issue of criterion and principles for identification of specific bands for 3G services, COAI wants globally harmonised common spectrum identified by ITU-R. With interference-free operations, optimal use of spectrum (minus guard band who cause wastage), global roaming and global availability of equipment, COAI sought allotment in 2.1 Ghz as identified by WARC-92, saying other countries are reframing 1,900 Mhz to this band.

AUSPI has sought sufficient upfront allocation for better planning therefore allocation in 1900 Mhz for CDMA.

Tatas seek 1870-1910 Mhz for CDMA, 1920-1940 Mhz for GSM while Reliance wants 800/1900 Mhz for CDMA service.